Not quite as ferocious as Zuul perhaps, but still…those gatekeepers!

Oz gatekeeper
Gatekeeper from The Wizard of Oz

Gatekeepers are – by definition, I suppose – intimidating individuals. How else could they keep out the riff-raff? In the writing world, those obstacles take on the form of agents, editors, and publishers…all with the goal of assuring quality publications for the literary world.

At least that’s what we hope.

But if you’re a writer like me, you’ve railed against the wall gate for its implacable, ever-changing rules that seem to require a super-secret password and handshake to get past. My query spreadsheet (yes, I keep a spreadsheet) has been around so long and is filled with so many rejections that I’ve started dividing it up by year just to avoid the discouragement of seeing the full list every time I open it.

My first novel, Forty & Out, garnered thirty-nine rejections (yes, some sent too early in the process while I was learning the ropes – but I did learn!). While I know that’s not a lot compared to the likely apocryphal numbers bandied about by now-legends of the writing world, I’d given up on the MS and moved on to novel 2 (3?) by the time I sent magical 39. (Side note: a woman at one of my early readings asked, “Forty & Out got 39 rejections before ‘yes’? Maybe if you’d called it Thirty & Out it would have been published sooner!” <ba-dum tish!>)

The gatekeeper mentality was one of several parallels I noted last year when I entered the political realm. I naively expected there to be some reasonable process of candidate vetting, but such a thing doesn’t exist – at least at the level I encountered. The local party was more concerned with finding a willing candidate with the appropriate “D” after their name than looking at qualifications and experience. At the national level, I learned that qualifications and experience take a backseat to financial backing and the depth of a candidate’s call sheet for fundraising. Depressing, to say the least, and one of several reasons I’ll never take on that particular challenge again.

As for my writing, I have yet to reach my long-dreamt of goal of landing an agent. Instead, I’ve been published with two small presses (the first went out of business shortly before novel #2 was to be released…but that’s a story for another day). And as I watch fellow writers find an agent and a big(ger) publishing house and a multiple-book contract, it’s hard not to be discouraged (and yes, a bit jealous). When do I get my secret decoder ring to slip past the elite gatekeepers?

Many authors these days avoid those roadblocks altogether and go straight to self-publishing, “indie” now, as that process sheds (some of) the stigma of the vanity presses of yore. But to do it right, self-pub has its own set of obstacles, requiring still more time and several other skill sets (cover design, editing, formatting, marketing) – or the money to hire professionals to handle those tasks.

Self-pub is not for me, for all those reasons and more. As I tell my students, we need to define what “success” as a writer means to us individually. For now, I’ll keep confronting the gatekeepers, honing my skills, and hoping for the day those larger, more imposing gates swing open for me.

What’s your definition of writing success? And how do you handle those intimidating gatekeepers?

8 responses to “Not quite as ferocious as Zuul perhaps, but still…those gatekeepers!”

  1. Best of luck! I keep working on building my author platform. Whether indie published or traditionally published, we need to do the marketing ourselves. Besides writing, I put most of my efforts there. It keeps me busy so I don’t obsess over queries I have out.


    1. I so agree! And focusing on the writing itself is the only way to maintain a modicum of sanity in this crazy business. Thanks!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I hear you, sister, and share your journey…thanks for the honesty in this piece.


    1. Always good to know we’re not alone. 😉


  3. My father is currently taking the self publishing route as he couldn’t get an agent. He just missed the “theme” window for his book. I think I would be just as happy to self publish as he is, but I think ultimately I’d love to meet those elite gatekeepers. This was refreshing and comforting, thank you.


    1. Good luck to both of you! Ultimately, we’re all in this together.


  4. I’m with you all the way on this. I can’t count the number of agents who said “You’re the real deal” (and other variants of that) BUT we want a book like “Girl On A Train.” My short fiction has fared better. Literary mags don’t seem to care about that and my stories get pubbed within 3-5 submissions. I trudge onward. What else can you do?


    1. Congrats on the short story success! And yes, we keep going…what else indeed?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: